What Are the Safest and Most Dangerous Cities for Drivers?


Auto accidents are among the leading causes of death in the U.S. each year, so if you're looking to play the odds you might want to consider moving to the city where the fewest crashes occur: Fort Collins, Colo. According to the 10th annual "Allstate America's Best Drivers Report," the Centennial State's fourth-most-populous city is the safest place to be behind the wheel. Fort Collins is no stranger to the honor, which it's held for four consecutive years.

Related: Speediest and Slowest States: Where Does Yours Rank?

"Fort Collins has placed in the top 10 every year since the report's inception," Allstate said in a statement. "This year, the results indicate the average driver in Fort Collins will experience an auto collision every 14.2 years, which is 29.6 percent less likely than the national average of every 10 years."

Fort Collins isn't the only Colorado city among the safest in the nation. The top 20 also includes Colorado Springs and Lakewood at Nos. 14 and 19, respectively. Meanwhile, among the top 20 least safe cities, California is home to four — Glendale, San Francisco, Los Angeles and Oakland — and Massachusetts has three in the top five alone, with Worcester taking the top spot with a 134.8 percent increased likelihood of an accident every 4.3 years, followed by Boston and Springfield at Nos. 2 and 4, respectively.

Allstate comes up with its rankings by analyzing company claims data to determine the likelihood that drivers in the 200 largest U.S. cities will be in a vehicle collision compared with the national average. Data from a two-year period spanning January 2011 to December 2012 was considered.

According to the "America's Best Drivers" report, the top 10 safest cities to drive in, followed by the likelihood of drivers in that city getting in an accident compared with the national average, and the average number of years between collisions, are as follows:

1. Fort Collins, Colo.; 29.6 percent less likely; 14.2 years
2. Brownsville, Texas; 29.5 percent less likely; 14.2 years
3. Boise, Idaho; 28.4 percent less likely; 14 years
4. Kansas City, Kan.; 22.4 percent less likely; 12.9 years
5. Huntsville, Ala.; 20.3 percent less likely; 12.6 years
6. Montgomery, Ala.; 19.4 percent less likely; 12.4 years
7. Visalia, Calif.; 19.1 percent less likely; 12.4 years
8. Laredo, Texas; 18.3 percent less likely; 12.2 years
9. Madison, Wis.; 17.8 percent less likely; 12.2 years
10. Olathe, Kan.; 17.5 percent less likely; 12.1 years

On the other end of the safety spectrum, the 10 cities where drivers are most likely to be in a crash, again followed by the likelihood of drivers getting in an accident and the average number of years between crashes, are as follows:

1. Worcester, Mass.; 134.8 percent more likely; 4.3 years
2. Boston; 129.9 percent more likely; 4.4 years
3. Washington, D.C.; 97.3 percent more likely; 5.1 years
4. Springfield, Mass; 85.8 percent more likely; 5.4 years
5. Providence, R.I.; 85.1 percent more likely; 5.4 years
6. Baltimore; 84.9 percent more likely; 5.4 years
7. Glendale, Calif.; 72.6 percent more likely; 5.8 years
8. Alexandria, Va.; 68.2 percent more likely; 5.9 years
9. Philadelphia; 61.2 percent more likely; 6.2 years
10. New Haven, Conn.; 59.1 percent more likely; 6.3 years


Robert Crum/iStock/Thinkstock; Allstate infographic

By Matt Schmitz | August 28, 2014 | Comments (7)


I'm surprised Los Angeles, CA isn't on that list. My brief time there was a tad frightening, especially since I was the one mostly behind the wheel.

I can only imagine how much worse these cities are by comparison.


Absolutely agree with you Jon. I live in LA and the driving skills here are atrocious. Speeding, weaving in and out, cell phone usage, distracted driving, no turn signals,a combination of aggression and cluelessness, ignoring red lights, last minute turns....the list goes on. I always tell my husband we're one step above China. Look at how many accidents occur after the slightest shower.

I've comfortably driven all over the world; Japan, Australia, Germany, etc. and in major cities around the US, and driving in LA still intimidates me

Connie C

Seriously? Laredo is on the "safest" list? Having driven in Laredo on more than one occasion it would be near the top of my "worst" list.


Having driven a lot in 1,2 and 5 and lived in 3,4 and 10, I can attest to that Worst list!


I live in 9 and am always appalled by the way people drive. I can't tell you how many people fail to signal, pull away from lights before they change, pass on the wrong side of the road, use turning lanes to pass, fail to stop at stop signs, tailgate, and do all the other things that make driving an issue. I never used to think it was bad but I do now. The other cities listed I can totally agree with.


I'm surprised that Fort Collins makes the top of the list. I find the driving there fast and aggressive, especially for the lack of density of the area. The stretch of I25 between Ft. Collins and Mead is the only place CDOT has seen fit to post signs warning against aggressive driving.


Chicago should be up there too, but I guess the east coast density makes the percentages higher there. Boston drivers truly are the worst anywhere though, even worse than New Jersey.

Post a Comment 

Please remember a few rules before posting comments:

  • If you don't want people to see your email address, simply type in the URL of your favorite website or leave the field empty.
  • Do not mention specific car dealers by name. Feel free to mention your city, state and brand.
  • Try to be civil to your fellow blog readers. This blog is not a fan or enthusiast forum, it is meant to help people during the car-buying process and during the time between purchases, so shoppers can keep a pulse on the market.
  • Stay on topic. We want to hear your opinions and thoughts, but please only comment about the specified topic in the blog post.
view posting rules

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Search Results

KickingTires Search Results for

Search Kicking Tires

KickingTires iPhone App