Suction Wars: The HondaVac Versus My DustBuster

Dust-vs-hondavac

Kids are great. One thing they're definitely not, however, is tidy. My family spends much of the weekend on the road, logging lots of miles and meals in the car — add a 3-year-old to the mix and you can guarantee a mess or two. Each Sunday we return with a little more than we left with, usually extra sand in our shoes or the remnants of en-route snacks. The last thing I do before returning a test car is give it a good once-over with my DustBuster.

When Honda debuted the first in-van vacuum system in the 2014 Odyssey, I was eager to test if it would add a little convenience to my weekly car-cleaning ritual. But how does it hold up against my trusty Black & Decker DustBuster? I peppered all three rows of the Odyssey with sand and Cheerios to find out.

IMG_7371
Round 1: Ease of Use

Winner: HondaVac

My cordless DustBuster's base is screwed into my utility room wall — pretty tough to beat in the easy department, but the HondaVac's integrated design earns it a win in this category. It's completely enclosed in a panel behind the third row, so the system doesn't take up any cargo space. The removable trash canister, expandable hose and two attachments are built into the driver's-side cargo wall and are very easy to pull out and put away; each tool snaps into place.

One big bonus is that it's always there, so you can quickly clean up at the beach or a hotel when on a road trip.

The HondaVac will run indefinitely when the car is on and for up to eight minutes when it's in accessory mode. My rechargeable-battery-powered DustBuster runs for about 10 minutes.

In terms of clean up, however, the DustBuster has it in the bag — pun intended. Although I didn't have to use the owner's manual to figure out how to empty the HondaVac's dirt bin, there were definitely more steps required than with my DustBuster. The DustBuster also has a washable filter and dirt canister; Honda dealers will sell you replacement filters for around $20-$29 and bags for about $15, according to Jessica Fini, Honda public relations assistant manager.

IMG_7394
Round Two: Suction

Winner: HondaVac

Both vacuums easily sucked up spilled Cheerios, but the HondaVac rounded up all the sand in fewer passes than the DustBuster. It's no wonder the suction feels heavy-duty — Honda worked with ShopVac to develop the system. The HondaVac is also more powerful than my DustBuster; it's rated at 12 volts versus the DustBuster's 9.6 volts.

Both vacuums fail in the liquids department, however. The DustBuster can't handle them and although the HondaVac technically can, Fini says it's not recommended. "The hose is quite long and if liquid gets stuck in the hose then it can smell," she said. Yuck; find another solution for juice box spills.

IMG_7407
Round Three: Range

Winner: Split

The idea of a cordless, hand-held DustBuster is that it can go everywhere — and mine does, but the HondaVac wasn't too far behind. The automaker says the hose and attachments can get to every corner of the van and although I found that to be true, cleaning the front floormats was a stretch.

The HondaVac's tools were extremely handy, however. The wide-mouth extension made sucking up sand easier, and the narrow tubelike one helped scoop Cheerios out of hard-to-reach crevices, like next to a child-safety seat. My DustBuster has no such fancy extensions, but is very familiar with the cracks between the seats.

IMG_7416
Round Four: Cost

Winner: DustBuster

At $29.99, the DustBuster wins big in this category. The HondaVac is much more expensive — several thousands of dollars more, in fact. That's because it's standard only on the Odyssey's Touring Elite trim level and not optional on any other model; this top-line trim starts at a hefty $45,280, including destination.

Results: Split Decision

In the end, the HondaVac lived up to my high expectations. Its powerful suction and easy operation will help keep parents sane when kids inevitably trash the van. The reality, however, is that with such a high price, few families will get to benefit from it unless Honda widens availability. According to Fini, it could happen. "We are always studying the market and customers' reaction to features," she said.

Related
Research the 2014 Honda Odyssey
Could In-Car Messes Be a Thing of the Past With 2014 Honda Odyssey's Vacuum?
Video of the Honda Odyssey Vacuum in Action

Comments 

jfbramfeld

I have no doubt that the Honda vacuum is more powerful, but volts is irrelevant. Volts times amps, which is roughly watts, is the important number.

Jay

Mistake on Honda's part to offer this only on a top of the line model. I could see more people spending the extra bucks for this as a stand-alone option.

Bob

+1 to jfbramfeld on the math. Furthermore, there are other factors that contribute to a vacuum's effectiveness (e.g., how well the hose attachments are designed relative to the surfaces being cleaned). The important factor, though, is how well the entire package ends up working. The HondaVac seems to be the winner, according to the article.

Regarding pricing: maybe Honda can make money using the razors-and-blades business model if they make the HondaVac a reasonably-priced option with wide availability--and then charge a hefty amount for bags and filters.

carma

Maybe Honda could add one of those hair trimmer attachments to the vacuum so busy moms can trim the kids hair or the dog while driving and talking on the phone.

J

Voltage multiply current is not "roughly" power. It IS power...

Post a Comment 

Please remember a few rules before posting comments:

  • If you don't want people to see your email address, simply type in the URL of your favorite website or leave the field empty.
  • Do not mention specific car dealers by name. Feel free to mention your city, state and brand.
  • Try to be civil to your fellow blog readers. This blog is not a fan or enthusiast forum, it is meant to help people during the car-buying process and during the time between purchases, so shoppers can keep a pulse on the market.
  • Stay on topic. We want to hear your opinions and thoughts, but please only comment about the specified topic in the blog post.
view posting rules

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Search Results

KickingTires Search Results for

Search Kicking Tires

KickingTires iPhone App
Ask.cars.com