What's the Most Affordable Midsize Sedan?

Mostaffordablesedancrop

The midsize sedan is one of the most popular segments in the U.S. It serves as a family car, commuter, road tripper and more.

Because of this popularity, automakers offer a dizzying amount of styles and options for their midsizers. This differing content makes it hard for car shoppers to compare apples to apples from one automaker to the next.

We analyzed the segment for the features most drivers would want in a car of this class and uncovered some surprising results.

Most Affordable Midsize Sedan

To arrive at the specific trim levels for our analysis we wanted models with a certain level of content that most car shoppers desire.

Required were:

  • Automatic transmission
  • Cruise control
  • USB
  • Bluetooth
  • Power windows
  • Power driver’s seat
  • Backup camera

Most midsize-car shoppers are choosing cars with at least this much equipment. Out of more than 30,000 new Honda Accords in Cars.com’s inventory, 67% were the midlevel Sport trim … or higher. For the Nissan Altima, that number was 65%.

We also included five years of gas costs at the current price and driving ratio provided by the EPA. Many midsize sedans are boasting impressive fuel-economy numbers these days, which is helping keep shoppers out of the crossover or SUV camp.

Here are more findings from our analysis:

  • The Kia Optima was $645 less expensive than the next most affordable sedan. 
  • The Kia Optima Hybrid and Ford Fusion Hybrid were more affordable after five years than seven other non-hybrids on our list.
  • The Ford Fusion Hybrid was $1,550 more affordable than the non-hybrid Fusion because it's better equipped at the trim level that fit our criteria and gets significantly better gas mileage.
  • The Fusion Hybrid’s purchase price is $3,200 more than the standard Fusion.
  • Chrysler's 200 and Dodge's Avenger don't offer a backup camera — not even as an option.
  • The all-wheel-drive Subaru Legacy will cost less at the pump than front-wheel-drive Chevy Malibu, Fusion or Volkswagen Passat.
  • The 2014 Passat will go on sale in August; VW promises better fuel efficiency as well as trim levels with more content at lower prices. However, these details weren’t available before we published.

Related
What's the Most Affordable Compact Sedan?
Is the 2013 Toyota RAV4 the Most Affordable Compact Crossover?
Research More Sedans

Comments 

Jay

After MY analysis, the difference in base price to get this equipment or options is around $10K. That's a lot of cash to not even get the top level model. At least you get navigation on the Sonata...

Tony

I disagree with everything that is written here

Shorebreak

Which one of these 'all look the same' vehicles retains the highest value at trade-in time?

Highdesertcat

"Which one of these 'all look the same' vehicles retains the highest value at trade-in time?"

Camry and Accord both retain the highest value at trade-in time, and Kia, VW and Hyundai sedans the least (in my area).

Tony

Which one of these has original tires that can last through 5 years period?

Highdesertcat

None of them.

Tony

Looks like car manufacturers go in the way of printer manufacturers with "trial version" of OEM tires. Although, my 2011 Mazda3 has a real set. 30K+ and about half life.

Highdesertcat

With the new formulation of rubber compounds to improve ride, handling and stopping, the tires of today wear faster and are less-resistant to the ravages of sun, salts and urea.

The tires on my wife's 2012 Grand Cherokee lasted a bit over 24K miles before being deemed 'questionable" for high speed driving. (You can tell by wear, rounded edges, thin cracks in the sidewall and abrasion)

The tires on my 2011 Tundra lasted ~ 25K miles before the gravel/dirt roads and hauling/towing duties began to show serious wear&tear on tread and sidewalls.

Best after-market tires for me have been Michelin. They ride good, have lots of grip, and seem to last longer than any OEM tire I ever owned.

Worst tires ever for me have been Firestone. They truly suck and can even kill you if they come apart on you at speed while on the road deck. It's happened more than once to more than a few, resulting in massive recalls.

Tony

Let me guess. Your GC came with GoodYear and Tundra with Dunlop. Both cars are 4WD.

bd

And yet, it's the Camry with an average transaction price that's lower than the top 8 selling midsize sedans - $1,700 less than the Optima.

Highdesertcat

Tony, you are right on both counts, but my Tundra is 2WD, long bed, DoubleCab.

Both vehicles came with 20" alloy wheels. Had to special order the Michelin tires through Discount Tire. Took a week but is worth it.

Ride is more supple. Steering more responsive and feedback less obtrusive with Michelins instead of OEMs.

On our Japan-built 2008 Highlander I put 18" Yokohamas because that's what it came with originally and we got good mileage out of them.

New Yokos, also made in Japan, seem to wear faster. Don't know why. I run them at 33psi all around. Ditto the GC.

On the Tundra, 32psi out front, 28 psi out back empty (loaded = 36psi).

critic

Not surprised that stinkin' diesel is the most expensive sedan to own. All the bragging about great mileage doesn't change the economics of diesel ownership and the news is not good. Camry hybrid is twice the car of a VW TDI and costs half as much to drive in the city.

Post a Comment 

Please remember a few rules before posting comments:

  • If you don't want people to see your email address, simply type in the URL of your favorite website or leave the field empty.
  • Do not mention specific car dealers by name. Feel free to mention your city, state and brand.
  • Try to be civil to your fellow blog readers. This blog is not a fan or enthusiast forum, it is meant to help people during the car-buying process and during the time between purchases, so shoppers can keep a pulse on the market.
  • Stay on topic. We want to hear your opinions and thoughts, but please only comment about the specified topic in the blog post.
view posting rules

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Search Results

KickingTires Search Results for

Search Kicking Tires

KickingTires iPhone App
Ask.cars.com