Is a Luxury Booster Seat Worth It?

6a00d83451b3c669e20168eb8c5d0d970c-800wi
The editors at Cars.com have kids ranging in age from newly born to newly off to college, with the vast majority of them in booster seats. While the laws vary from state to state, the federal government recommends that kids stay in booster seats until a seat belt fits properly (typically when kids are 4-feet-9-inches tall or 11 to 12 years old). This means that your kids are going to be in that belt-positioning booster seat longer than any other child-safety seat you purchase and much longer than that cool-looking $800 Bugaboo stroller you just had to have before they were born.

Since you'll be looking at that booster seat day in and day out for many, many years, it might make sense to budget a little extra money to buy the safest seat with an aesthetic quality that doesn't make you want to puke fuzzy rainbows and pink unicorns (see above pic).

Maxicosi_rodi_brownearth_2011_US_930x1050_03.ashx
A "disappearing" booster seat does more than just appeal to parents' style sense. It's much less noticeable to kids as well. Your precious one will have less stigma to deal with when Mom makes them stay in a booster seat until age 11.5 when "all of [their] friends' moms let them ride without booster seat ... like ... forever ago." Trust me; I know a little something about that.

We've dug up two different booster seats with clean, streamlined looks that will blend seamlessly into your vehicle's backseat, whether your family hauler is a Mazda or a Mercedes.

The Maxi Cosi Rodi XR Booster sells for about $180 and comes in a slew of colors such as Brown Earth, Lapis Blue and Total Black to match a car's upholstery. This seat starts out as a high-back booster with adjustable wings (above), a great feature for kids who still nap in the car because it keeps their heads up in a comfortable position rather than slumping forward over the top of their seat belt. The height-adjustable back can be removed for bigger kids (below), transitioning this seat into a backless booster.

Maxicosi_rodi_brownearth_2011_US_930x1050_01.ashx
The Clek line of booster seats offers a high-back version, the Oobr (below) that comes is a sleek all-black model called Drift ($274.99), which nearly disappears in vehicles with black leather seats. Like the Maxi Cosi Rodi XR, the Oobr also converts from a high-back model with deep side wings to a backless model for bigger kids. According to Clek, it also features a Detachable Drink-Thingy, aka a cupholder. Gotta love that!

Oobr_design
Clek seats are installed using rigid Latch connectors (and then the kids install themselves into the booster seats using the seat belt just as they would with any other belt-positioning booster). This helps keep the booster seat stable and from becoming a projectile in a crash. From my own experience, it keeps the booster seat from wiggling its way over the seat belt buckle, a cause of buckling frustration for kids.

Olli_hero
The low-back, sleek Clek Olli (above) also comes in an all-black Jet ($99) and is my booster seat of choice. Until I recently sold my Volvo C30, I kept two installed in the backseat, and they looked built-in. I was able to keep my oldest daughter in this setup until she was 11.5 without visually disturbing the zen of my much-enjoyed car, and more importantly to her preteen self, none of the other kids waiting in the carpool lane could see it.

Parents, are you willing to spend more money on a booster seat? Tell us in the comment section below.

Related
Car Seat Basics Part Three: Beyond the Booster
31 Booster Seats Named Best Bets by IIHS
Car Seat Checks

Comments 

I think this is ridiculous. Why should kids have to sit in a booster seat until 11-12 anyway. Kids have been out of boosters seats at younger ages for years and they turned out fine. I think that people are starting to coddle children more and more over time and this needs to stop so kids can learn how to be part of a society, not sheltered from it. I think these seats are just a gimmick that stupid parents will give into because they want to seem hip to everyone else.

Matt C.

Amen, Angela. Preach it, speak that truth.

Ben

Angela, do you think this kid would "turn out fine" if he were in a crash and his neck took the full force of his body moving forward as shown at left? http://www.iihs.org/research/topics/child_restraints/belted.jpg

I shudder to think of how bad the injury would be.

CPST

The kids who didn't sit in booster seats and got in serious accidents aren't here to tell about it.
You can't say younger kids were fine without booster seats when younger kids that need to be in booster seats are dying every single day from their number one killer..car accidents. Educate yourself.

Carolyn A.

Absolutely. Older kids need boosters to be protected from deadly crash forces, so why not be comfortable? My daughter has a Clek Oobr and is super-comfortable in it.

Nate

Does this apply to midgets, err I'm sorry vertically challenged individuals?

Booster seats are not a "gimmick" to make mom and dad hip...children dont want to be in them and they fight about it because uneducated mothers/fathers/caregivers allow their children to not sit in one. A fight every morning is not what I am looking forward to when I purchase said "gimmick". It is solely for the safety of my child. This is not coddling children, it is ensuring vehicular safety. Maybe you should learn the purpose and safety of them and then speak about the issue. And yes, when I purchase my child a booster seat, it will be the Clek, I like the rigid connect and the primarily all metal frames that Clek uses.

Amanda

It's sad to see how many uneducated parents there are when it comes to this matter and how they don't understand the risks they are taking by not taking proper precautions while traveling.

As for brand names or not, just because something is more expensive than another product doesn't make it better. All products have to meet the same safety standards. Pick a product based on how it would benefit your family.

I live in Sweden - we keep our kids in rear facing seats until they are four and we keep them in booster seats until they are the as tall (?!) as Kylie Minogue. We don't take lightly on car safety (we build Volvos) and our government has a vision of 0 deaths in traffic. I blog about family cars and I get to hear stories from readers, heart breaking stuff. So please make sure to keep your kids as safe in the cars as possible, a lost child is NEVER worth it!!!!!


This is nice post which I was awaiting for such an article and I have gained some useful information from this site. Thanks for sharing this information.

sid

Yo Angela & Matt: Where ignorance is bliss, tis folly to be wise!

Post a Comment 

Please remember a few rules before posting comments:

  • If you don't want people to see your email address, simply type in the URL of your favorite website or leave the field empty.
  • Do not mention specific car dealers by name. Feel free to mention your city, state and brand.
  • Try to be civil to your fellow blog readers. This blog is not a fan or enthusiast forum, it is meant to help people during the car-buying process and during the time between purchases, so shoppers can keep a pulse on the market.
  • Stay on topic. We want to hear your opinions and thoughts, but please only comment about the specified topic in the blog post.
view posting rules

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Search Results

KickingTires Search Results for

Search Kicking Tires

KickingTires iPhone App
Ask.cars.com