Bench Seats Versus Captain's Chairs

Ford-flex
I've been test-driving the 2013 Ford Flex this week, which I've been waiting to drive for years. Overall, my impressions are highly favorable (stay tuned for the complete review) with the exception of one major point. My test car came equipped with a second-row bench seat, so the car seats a total of seven. Captain's chairs in the second row are also available, taking the number of seats down to six. While many families may think they want the extra seating capacity that comes with a second-row bench seat, I'm here to save you from making that mistake.

If you have kids in child-safety seats or booster seats, you're most likely to put them in the second row's outboard positions where a parent, grandparent, caregiver or carpool driver has the easiest access to help them climb in and out and get buckled and unbuckled. The problem is in most three-row SUVs like the Flex the only real access to the third row is by sliding, folding and/or flipping one of the outboard seats in the second row. When a car seat is installed in the outboard, there are limited options as to getting to the third row.

Option 1: You could remove a child-safety seat from the second row and fold, slide, flip and/or tumble the seat forward. Then let the kids climb into the third row, fold the second-row seat back into place and then reinstall the child-safety seat and hope your kids don't repeat the foul language you've used while completing this maneuver.

Captain-bench-3
Option 2: You could have third-row passengers step on the bench seat with their grimy, germy shoes and then fold their legs up like an Olympic hurdler and catapult over the bench seat into the third row. Warning: This only works with kids small enough to squeeze between the top of the bench seat and the roofliner.

Captain-bench-4
Option 3: If you only have one third-row passenger, you can keep half of the third row folded flat and then have your child climb in and out of the car through the cargo area and hope nobody calls the authorities to report that you're locking your kids in the "trunk."

Option 4: You can get captain's chairs.

Sure, you might think you're losing a precious extra seat by going with the captain's chairs, but that seat is small. My third daughter, who gets sandwiched in the middle position of my test cars' bench seats regularly, says this position in most cases is too narrow to actually fit a person of any width. Apparently riding for an extended period of time with a butt cheek on each outboard seat belt buckle just isn't comfortable.

Captain-bench-1
Instead, why not do away with this useless center seat and turn it in into a passageway for easy access to the third row by getting captain's chairs? Even when a center console is between the two captain's chairs like in the Infiniti QX56, kids can easily step over the console and into the third row when needed.

Another benefit of captain's chairs is you typically have much more flexibility when positioning them, so you can adjust the each seatback to accommodate child-safety seats or booster seats of different sizes. And better yet, there seems to be an innate calmness that happens in a car where siblings each have their own defined space with a passageway between as delineation.

Captain-bench-2
There are a couple of exceptions to the above problem. Infiniti's new JX35 has a bench seat in the second row, but the passenger-side outboard seat slides forward and tilts slightly with a child-safety seat fully installed. This allows children to pass behind the seat and climb into the third row. The upcoming Nissan Pathfinder will have the same feature. And the Toyota Highlander offers a second-row bench seat that splits into thirds, and the center seat can be removed and stowed away, essentially converting the bench seat into captain's chairs.

Do you and you family have a three-row SUV with either a bench seat or captain's chairs? If so, what are the pros and cons for your family of the option you chose? Tell us in the comment section below.

Related
Research the 2013 Ford Flex
Family Car Buying Guide
More Family News

Comments 

Hiro

In our Ford Flex we also wanted the captain's seats with the refrigerator in the middle. If we have a 5th passenger we move one of the child seat to the 3rd row which can be accessed by pushing a button that folds the 2nd row seats up for easy access. But I believe the bench seats in the Flex fold 60/40 so we would probably use the same configuration.
I liked the Highlander setup where the middle seat can be stowed away when not used so the kids could climb in and get to the 3rd row through the middle aisle like a minivan.

Nate

We opted for the bench seat. Two youngsters, one 3 and in a convertible; the other 1 and still in a carrier. Yes, the arrangement you describe is accurate, but not the space available. My wife regularly takes the middle bench position, wedged between the two car seats, in order to feed or attend to the baby while we're on the go. No, it's not plush luxury, but it works. For longer trips, or when we need to carry more adults, the older child's seat is quickly moved to the third row. My only complaint in selecting the 2nd row bench is that it doesn't slide. I wouldn't mind giving the 3rd row passengers a little more room, although my 6' tall parents were both reasonably comfortable riding back there.

Louie

Actually there's another option you didn't think of: when we had this car we would put one kid in a car seat in the third row on one side, say the passenger. The other kid in a car seat in second row on the same side. That way new passengers can first tumble the second row seat, drivers side and climb into the third row seat, drivers side. Additional passengers obviously end up in second row drivers side. The only downside is that it may be a little weird having your kids in separate rows when there are no other passengers, but my son LOVED being all the way in the back. Probably solves a lot of sibling rivalry issues, too.

Alicia W

We have the middle bench seat and sit our 2 yr old and newborn each in the second row window spots with their large car seats. Contemplating going to captains chairs. We have 7-12 hour rides to visit family and Enjoy having passengers with us when we have company. However, they've had to enter through the trunk area. Not so safe, etc. although I can sit between the kids on the bench during a long ride I almost think the captains chairs will make life easier for us. Thoughts?

Jason

we have captain seats in the 2nd row. we have enjoyed them but when transporting 6 kids ..well you cant. I need a suburban size vehicle whereas the 2nd row has at lease one seat that flips forward to make access easy to the third row.

Jess

Does no one know that it is safer to have one kid in the center and one behind the passenger seat? When in a car seat, behind the driver is the least safe. I am set on a bench seat because for a car seat, booster, etc., the center is still the safest place. If I need to rise in back with them, I sot behind the driver.

Post a Comment 

Please remember a few rules before posting comments:

  • If you don't want people to see your email address, simply type in the URL of your favorite website or leave the field empty.
  • Do not mention specific car dealers by name. Feel free to mention your city, state and brand.
  • Try to be civil to your fellow blog readers. This blog is not a fan or enthusiast forum, it is meant to help people during the car-buying process and during the time between purchases, so shoppers can keep a pulse on the market.
  • Stay on topic. We want to hear your opinions and thoughts, but please only comment about the specified topic in the blog post.
view posting rules

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Search Results

KickingTires Search Results for

Search Kicking Tires

KickingTires iPhone App
Ask.cars.com