Cars.com Mileage Challenge 4.1: Luxury Crossovers
Memorial Day is nigh, and that means the summer driving season will soon kick off. AAA recently reported that it expects 27 million Americans — that’s 83% of all Memorial Day travelers — to hit the road this weekend. That’s down from 2007 but up nearly 3 percent over last year, when sky-high gas prices took quite a toll on Memorial Day travel.
Gas may be cheap, but gas mileage is still top of mind. That’s why it’s time for another installment of Cars.com’s Mileage Challenge. After last fall’s econocar shootout, we felt ready for something a bit more upscale. So we turned to entry-level luxury crossovers, a segment once dominated by the Lexus RX and BMW X3. With starting prices around $35,000, that segment now includes models from at least 10 premium brands, most of which boast lower prices, better gas mileage and cozier cabins than their larger SUV siblings. We matched one of the latest — Volvo’s all-new XC60 — against the venerable X3 and the Land Rover LR2 in its sophomore season.
Like before, we set some ground rules: No open windows or moonroofs, and no using cruise control. We drove as we normally would — none of this hypermiling business — and filled the tires to their recommended pressure before starting out. Our trip began and ended at the same gas pump in Aurora, Ill., and took us into Chicago on busy city/suburban roads, up to Milwaukee on I-94, down to Rockford, Ill., on I-43, and back to Aurora on I-39 and I-88. All told, the trip totaled 315 miles, 85% of which was highway driving.
The consensus on cabin temperature in past drives was 68 degrees, so we set each car’s automatic climate control there and hit “Auto.” Left to their own devices, the systems doled out mileage-hurting air conditioning: A Volvo spokesman told us the XC60’s Auto mode runs the A/C compressor full-time, and BMW spokesman Dave Buchko and Land Rover product manager Skip Pavlik said the same. (Pavlik said the load on the engine varies depending on how much A/C is needed, though.) Minor variables, probably, but we report them in the interest of full disclosure.
Details on each model:
- 2009 BMW X3: 3.0-liter inline-six, six-speed automatic; 17/24 mpg city/highway (20 mpg combined)
- 2009 Land Rover LR2: 3.2-liter inline-six, six-speed automatic; 15/22 mpg city/highway (17 mpg combined)
- 2010 Volvo XC60: 3.0-liter, turborcharged inline-six, six-speed automatic; 16/22 mpg city/highway (18 mpg combined)
Stay tuned for the results later this week, but feel free to offer your predictions below.
2009|BMW|X3
2009|Land Rover|LR2
2010|Volvo|XC60
Previous
Subscribe to our feed
Email us your tips!
I predict the X3 wins, gets upper 20s purely highway, and ~25 total.
BMW-1st, thank you Valvetronic
Volvo-2nd, the turbocharger will help to keep the transmission in a high gear.
Land Rover-3rd-close to xc60 due to camshaft switching system on engine. (which allows for low valve lift with larger throttle opening)
http://us1.webpublications.com.au/static/images/articles/i1058/105866_00mg.jpg
that picture almost makes it look like that white santa fe is part of the test, too. lol
Broq
No cruise control and you drove as you normally would. Does this mean that you don't usually use cruise control? Are you the person who passes me and then slows down, playing "leapfrog in a car" for miles on end while I cruise at a steady 74 mph?
John--
I certainly hope not. In light or medium traffic I try to stay in the right lane unless passing. I'll use cruise control once traffic thins, but ever since Mileage Drive 1 -- when some drivers used cruise control but others didn't, and we had to contend with less-than-scientific estimates for how much each person used it -- we've decided to keep that variable out.
KM
I agree, not using cruise control is......questionable. Are all 3 vehicles going to drive in a pack. What if one "driver" drives much faster? Either way I think the LandRover finishes last. BMW 2nd and the Volvo #1.
The Volvo XC60 and the LandRover LR2 look are surprisingly similar under the hood??
The Volvo XC60 and the LandRover LR2 look are surprisingly similar under the hood??