click on any photo to see a full image gallery
As the auto show season winds down, New York City took center stage. This year automakers really toned down the flashy, wild concepts to let new production models sink in a little better — one concept was even ready to be tested on roads. Mike Hanley, David Thomas and Joe Wiesenfelder took out their red and green pens one last time to decide which vehicles are worthy of showgoers’ time in New York.
2009 Nissan Maxima
David Thomas: Winner
I was surprised at how much better the Maxima looks in person. I still think the grille is too rectangular and Nissan could’ve integrated it better with the stylish headlights, but everything else about the Maxima screams winner. The interior is near Infiniti-quality, and there’s plenty of room in the back despite the car’s smaller size. The trunk is huge, too. Big-sedan fans should be very happy.
Mike Hanley: Winner
The new Maxima's upright grille was a bit jarring when I first saw photos of it, but after seeing it in person it's grown on me. There are interesting styling cues almost everywhere you look on the outside of this car. What put me more in the sedan's corner was its interior; like Dave, I think it offers materials that wouldn't be out of place in Nissan's Infiniti luxury brand. For a big car, however, I found the backseat to be pretty small.
Joe Wiesenfelder: Winner
Here's a switch: I was more accepting of the new Maxima’s styling than were the others when we got the photos earlier this week, but now I'm not sold on it. Specifically, I question how well the front-end treatment will work with darker paint. The headlights and grille blend into the show car's silver paint, blunting the impact. Nissan finally succeeded in making this model significantly nicer than the Altima on which it's based, but now I wonder if it's too far into Infiniti territory. One of two things is happening: Either Nissan doesn't need this model at all, or I'm not seeing the need. On its own merits, though, the Maxima's a winner.