2008 Detroit Auto Show Winners and Losers: Production Cars
There weren’t nearly as many new production cars at this year’s Detroit auto show compared to the array of concepts, but Cars.com’s Mike Hanley, David Thomas and Joe Wiesenfelder take on each with gusto.
Mike Hanley: Winner
If the BMW X6 is a success — which I think it will be with its muscular, athletic styling — it'll go to show that the AMC Eagle of the '80s really was before its time, as the X6 follows the path set forth by that all-wheel-drive hatchback. With a healthy helping of horsepower, the X6 looks like a smart way for BMW to attract more SUV shoppers without diluting the driving experience too much.
David Thomas: Loser
It’s neat-looking and I can’t wait to drive one with the turbo V-8, but otherwise the X6 doesn’t work for me. You can’t see out the back, you can’t fit in the backseat. It doesn’t have much utility at all, and it’s going to be expensive. Yeah, sign me up for that.
Joe Wiesenfelder: Loser
I like the idea of the X6, and I think it looks pretty good. I'm down on redundancy, though, and I don't see this model's necessity. I'd be more enthusiastic about the style and styling if it showed up as a next-generation X5.











Subscribe to our feed
Email us your tips!