IIHS: One-Third of Tested Booster Seats Not Recommended
Parents with young tots know that as their children grow in size, so too should their child-safety seats. Booster seats are the last phase before kids can do without supplemental restraints, and not only are they a good idea, it’s illegal to drive without them in 43 states and the District of Columbia. In recent Insurance Institute for Highway Safety tests of 41 different booster seats, though, many failed.
Of the 41 models tested, 13 are not recommended based on seat belt fit. It’s important to note that these aren’t crash-test results; booster seats do not provide crash protection. A good booster seat simply routes a seat belt across a child's bony parts, rather than soft parts — like the abdomen — that are more vulnerable to injury, according to IIHS.
Two types of booster seats were evaluated — backless boosters and high-back boosters — and they were tested in 31 different 2001-06 vehicles.
Overall, IIHS found backless boosters to generally provide better lap-belt fit, while high-back boosters generally did a better job at positioning shoulder belts. The IIHS ranking of Best Bet is given to boosters that do both well; a Good Bet provides merely adequate protection, and seats branded Not Recommended are deemed ineffective, leaving the lap belt partially or fully on the abdomen.
One other important find in this study is that three-in-one seats — meaning seats that can be reconfigured from a baby seat into a booster — were generally not well-received. Many three-in-one designs compromised the seat’s ability to provide good belt fit as a booster seat. Also, a booster seat’s cost didn’t necessary translate into a high ranking; the Graco TurboBooster (a $20 model) is rated a Best Bet. Check out the video here.
Below is a full list of all the models and rank:
- Safety Angel Ride Ryte backless
- Cosco/Dorel (Eddie Bauer) Summit
- Graco CarGo Zephyr
- Evenflo Big Kid Confidence
- Cosco/Dorel Traveler
- Compass B505
- Compass B510
- Evenflo Generations
- Dorel/Safety 1st (Eddie Bauer) Prospect
- Cosco Highback Booster
- Cosco/Dorel Alpha Omega
- Evenflo Chase Comfort Touch
- Safety 1st/Dorel Intera
- Graco TurboBooster
- Safety Angel Ride Ryte
- Recaro Young Sport
- Combi Kobuk
- Safety 1st/Dorel Apex 65
- Graco TurboBooster backless with clip
- Fisher-Price Safe Voyage backless with clip
- Combi Kobuk backless with clip
- Fisher-Price Safe Voyage
- Britax Parkway
- LaRoche Bros. Teddy Bear
- Safeguard Go backless with clip
- Volvo booster cushion
- Recaro Young Style
- Britax Monarch
Note: Unless the booster name indicates that it is a backless seat, all boosters are high-backs.