Hyundai Genesis Coupe Takes on Infiniti G37

Hyundai is charging relentlessly into new territories with its products. Witness the Veracruz, a three-row SUV that Hyundai regularly compares to the Lexus RX 350 (which, if a recent Motor Trend comparison is any indication, might not be such a wild notion). Earlier this year, the automaker said it set sedans like the BMW 5 Series and Mercedes-Benz E-Class as the benchmark for its new Genesis sedan, and now press materials for the 306-hp, V-6 Genesis coupe — rumored to be priced starting under $26,000 — tout the $35,000-plus Infiniti G37 as a possible competitor.

The comparison Hyundai made concerned performance capabilities, so we’ll have to wait until we drive one before we can deliver a final verdict. That doesn’t mean we can’t have a little fun, though; at last week’s New York auto show, I checked out the two cars back to back.

Styling
The Genesis coupe’s doors have two distinctly carved lines — one trailing off the front fenders, the other headed for the taillights — and the smartly executed trunk needs no spoiler to spice it up. The G37 looks cleaner but gentler, with upscale touches like a chrome lip atop the trunk and painted tailpipe surroundings. It needs a spoiler to look best, though.

My chief knock against the Genesis is the black plastic that’s everywhere: It’s in the grille, around the oblong tailpipes and inside the massive front air dam. The G37 dresses those areas up with chrome, paints them over or at the very least doesn’t make them so obvious.

The Genesis redeems itself with its wheels: The 19-inch, twin-spoke alloys on the show car had an expensive-looking dark silver finish. The G37 at the show had the Sport package’s wheels, an Infiniti representative told me. Even so, they didn’t prove quite as eye-catching.

Winner: Genesis Coupe, by a smidge

Interior
The Genesis coupe wins a few points here. The window switches have elegant clarity, the steering-wheel buttons are easier to discern than Infiniti’s mass of switches, and the woven headliner is softer than the G37’s stiff-feeling turf. In most other places, though, there isn’t much of a contest; the turn signal stalks lack the G37’s precise consistency, the doors and dashboard have hard plastics where Infiniti places handsomer materials, and typical features like a telescoping steering wheel and extendable sun visors are MIA.

Bear in mind that the auto show cars were early, preproduction models, so Hyundai may fix some of these issues before the cars hit dealerships. In its current state, the Genesis coupe still seems a bit rough around the edges.

Winner: G37

Seating & Storage
Where the G37’s dash seems to wrap closely around the driver, the Genesis coupe’s cockpit feels airier. Indeed, headroom seems better in the Hyundai (both cars had moonroofs), and the glove compartment and center console are much deeper. The cupholders in both cars sit behind the transmission, which gets in the way of manual shifting, but the G37’s seem like a worse offense — they’re positioned across the whole center tunnel, while the Genesis coupe’s are offset slightly to the right.

Expectedly, the G37’s seats had a higher grade of leather than the seats in the Genesis coupe, which felt somewhat rubbery in comparison. The backrests in both cars were too stiff for me, even with the lumbar support dialed all the way down. Neither backseat is a place I’d relish spending my time in, but the G37 at least allowed me to put my knees against the front seats. In the Genesis coupe, I had to spread ‘em to each side.

Winner: Tie

Performance?
Of course, static comparisons don’t mean much in performance cars like these. Thanks to a smooth-revving V-6 and one of the best manual transmissions out there, the G37 is a formidable competitor. I can’t speak to the Genesis coupe’s abilities, but this much I do know: According to preliminary specs, its 3.8-liter V-6 makes 306 hp and 263 pounds-feet of torque (310 hp with premium fuel). Both figures are short of the G37’s 330 hp and 270 pounds-feet, but the Hyundai achieves peak power at slightly lower rpm, which means you won’t rev to quite the heights you do in the G37. Last but not least, the V-6 Genesis coupe weighs a crucial 119 pounds less (3,549 versus 3,668) than a six-speed-manual G37 — not enough to bridge the power deficiency, but enough to significantly narrow the gap.

In the static contest, the G37 emerges a winner — though in typical Hyundai fashion, when pricing is released the Genesis coupe will probably smoke all contenders when it comes to overall value. As we often say after an auto show, stay tuned for when we get some seat time.

Comments

[nony]

The caption for the Genesis Coupe and Infiniti dashes are swapped.

[Dave T.]

nony,
that's just the picture browser. your cursor is hovering over the thumbnail of the other photo.

[George]

Maybe Nissan will install the 7 speed automatic into the G37 coupe for '09. It better be there for '10.

How much torque will the Genesis V6 make with premium, 265ft-lb, or better?

[J]

Come on now journalists.

People who regularly shops for Lexus and Infiniti won't even give a look at Hyundai.
So why put those 2 together?

On the other hand, you guys won't put the M3 vs STI.

[cody]

i can't give the styling nod to the genesis coupe... it's overstyled, tortured almost, similar to the first generation Tiburon.

[TQuarles]

Realistically I don't see how you can compare the G37 to a Hyundai in any aspect regardless at Hyundai's attempt to imitate the Infiniti. The G37 out performs every luxury coupe in it's class including the 3-Series coupe and the Mercedes CLK 350 and they compare it to a Hyundai. I agree with the earlier comment somebody shopping for a luxury performance coupe wouldn't even consider a Hyundai.

I am going to have to overwhelmingly agree with J and TQuarles. People who buy a luxury coupe are not buying for practicality, and luxury coupes don't have to satisfy a certain value quotient as other types of cars do. These people do not have kids and can buy whatever they want- not what they have to. Just think about it- anyone that buys a G,3, or CLK coupe could have had the sedan couterpart for less money. To me it is a bad idea for Hyundai to get into this image driven market- they should stick to crossovers and sedans. . . until their image catches up to their cars. IMO

BTW- that G looks really good with the wood- too bad it is really hard to get on like that.

Broq

[J]

Maybe I could go more extreme.
People who shops for the BMW 7 Series just won't give a you know what about the Hyundai Azera is bigger inside.
I believe I've said this before: Who is going to McD for lobster?

[pedro]

its funny how all this hyundai bashers arrogant pigs are talking about hyundai without not even ever tested one.

[Response]

Pedro, I don't think it's the fact that they haven't tested one yet, but it's more along the lines that Hyundai is encroaching territory that isn't traditionally theirs. Hyundai is a newcomer to an established game (that is, luxury + sports cars), but Hyundai has not established its own reputation for what it's trying to conquer, in this case, luxury sports cars (or luxury at all...) in the USA.

[sczech]

Maybe it isn't the idea to truly compare so as to see who is the winner, but to see how good Hyundai's car is.

[Tufast]

Hey guys wake up, the Genesis is a Luxury car, Hyundai just does not have enough cars under the Genesis name to warrant a whole new line yet. For those of you who think that people who own premium lux cars will not take a glance at the Genesis - you're wrong...I own a BMW 540i sport(M pkg) and was going to rid myself of this low reliability car for the a reliable Hyundai, except they didn't have a lux sport vehicle. Thats a different story now and since I no longer care for 4 doors, the Genesis coupe is right down my alley. It looks awesome from every angle, sort of derived from a Tiburon, but more refined. I've heard from a Hyundai exec that those numbers posted for the HP output etc are actually low-balled and in reality will be closer to 350HP for the V/6 with upped torque and they are working on outfitting the V/8 in the coupe in the near future...P.S. I also know several high end (BMW etc) car owners who are also interested in checking out the Genesis sedan....

[ckh]

People talk like they're rich. the point of the genesis coupe is to give good value for the money, meaning the people who have always dreamt of owning a brand new sports car will now be able to afford a good one instead of paying out of their buttox or leasing.

hyundai is robin hood. no need to be a greedy sellout. a car is a car and hyundai doesn't need extra knobs for you to have something gratifying in the driveway. can't bash a company that's moving forward and taking new steps.

everyone forgets hyundai had a factory turbo long before any other company had factory turbos. Scoupe 1.5 Turbo in 1994. it wasn't big but it still was.

the genesis sedan will not be as good or sporty as the 7 series, however people totally forget that parts, labor, and insurance will be lots cheaper!